Soundtrack Review: Goldeneye

Composed by: Eric Serra

Conducted by: Erica Serra & John Altman

After a six-year hiatus, the James Bond franchise was revived with Pierce Brosnan in the lead role. Goldeneye centers on radical Russians plotting to use an orbiting pulse weapon for their own evil ends, with James Bond trying to stop them. It was a tremendous hit, and spawned one of the few successful video game spin-offs. John Barry declined to return, and French song-writer and musician Eric Serra took over.

This is one of the most infamous movie scores in history, mainly because it’s a James Bond score. Almost entirely gone are the lush romantic themes and the orchestral style associated with the series. Instead there are a lot of electronics, with odd choral bursts and a cold, mechanical gong which admittedly sounds pretty cool. While failing to fit in with the James Bond franchise, this style of music does convey the atmosphere of a collapsed Soviet Union. There is an orchestra that is used, but not very often and never to the depth of John Barry or David Arnold.

While the score has been a source of controversy, most agree that Tina Turner’s opening number “Goldeneye” is great. It’s a catchy, sexy song with small hints of the James Bond theme. The opening notes have received much praise and there has been great lament that it they were never utilized by Serra in his score (no references to the entire song, really). David Arnold corrected this, using the notes in Tomorrow Never Dies’ “Hamburg Breakout”. There’s little in the way of themes at all. Much of the music ties together stylistically, but aside from the rare reference to the James Bond theme there’s a string suspense motif that first appears around the 4:15 mark in “We Share the Same Passions”. It’s effective for the film’s atmosphere, but is very pedestrian. The same track also has its own love theme which is okay. Much better is Natalya’s theme, which first appears bookending “Severnaya Suite” and later in “That’s What Keeps You Alone” and “Forever, James”.

The score kicks off with “Goldeneye Overture”, which sets the tone with its mechanistic percussion, dark electronics, and bursts of Russian-sounding choir. It’s one of the two tracks on album to feature the James Bond theme (albeit only parts of it), and even weaves in the opening of the Goldfinger theme. It’s not too bad a track, actually pretty cool. The James Bond theme appears more fully in “A Pleasant Drive Through St. Petersburg”. It’s one of several cues replaced in the film, as producers were so irked by the lack of a traditional version of the James Bond theme they had another composer produce an entirely different piece with more obvious statements of said theme. Said piece appears on some of the City of Prague Philharmonic Orchestra’s Bond compilations.

The rest of score is a mixed bag (I should also point out that many of the tracks are made up of several cues which are listed in the album’s booklet). “Ladies First” is the most obnoxious track, a bunch of rambling electronics. “We Share the Same Passions is simplistic romance cue that gets long-winded and boring. “A Little Surprise for You” is a take it or leave it cue. “Our Lady of St. Smolensk” is minute of escalating suspense featuring eastern choir. “Whispering Statues” starts with string music before a Russian choir takes over for a few seconds. After more Goldeneye gongs Serra plays some anonymous piano music which sounds too tragic for what’s happening on screen. “Run, Shoot, and Jump” is the closest to a full on orchestral action track and was edited into several parts of the final battle.

“Your Fatal Weakness” is chilling in its slow train-like dirge. “Dish Out of Water” starts off a bit dream-like before going into electronic percussion, concluding with two statements of an effective menacing motif. “The Scale to Hell” actually features two cues that were replaced in the film. The first, “Boris’ Lethal Pen”, is a building suspense cue that was probably taken out because of its annoying electric strikes. The second, “I Am Invincible” has bits of “Goldeneye Overture” and was supposed to play as Bond rushes to save the day towards the end. At the end is a love song written by Eric Serra himself which is both pretty bad and really long, clocking in at about six minutes.

I have trouble rating this score. I think because I like the movie and some of the instrumentation sounds cool and different I don’t have the dislike that other Bond fans have, but I have to admit that it was too radical a shift in musical styles, and some of the music is indeed bad. Those who love the movie are more likely to enjoy the music. I know my first listening could get a bit torturous at points.

 

Rating: 4/10

 

  1. Goldeneye (performed by Tina Turner) (4:46)
  2. Goldeneye Overture (4:24)
  3. Ladies First (2:44)
  4. We Share the Same Passions (4:46)
  5. A Little Surprise for You (2:02)
  6. Severnaya Suite (2:07)
  7. Our Lady of St. Molensk (1:01)
  8. Whispering Statues (3:26)
  9. Run, Shoot, and Jump (1:05)
  10. A Pleasant Drive Through St. Petersburg (4:28)
  11. Your Fatal Weakness (4:43)
  12. That’s What Keeps You Alone (3:17)
  13. Dish Out of Water (3:57)
  14. The Scale to Hell (3:43)
  15. Forever, James (2:01)
  16. The Experience of Love (written by Eric Serra) (5:57)
Advertisements

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s